Harris County - Judicial Misconduct

PEOPLE’S SIXTH AMENDMENT RIGHTS ARE BEING VIOLATED IN HARRIS COUNTY EVERY DAY

For decades, Harris County has not limited the caseloads for court-appointed attorneys, overloading attorneys with hundreds of cases, made worse by campaign contributions in a "pay campaign contributions in a "pay for play system." The result is extremely low quality of defense - no visits, no investigation, no research, no plan, no hope. Now, we have a chance to limit the caseloads of each court-appointed attorney.

Under the Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, you are guaranteed an attorney, even if you cannot afford one. But merely having a lawyer assigned to your case isn’t enough. To ensure your constitutional rights are protected and that you aren’t railroaded by the system, you need a skilled and compassionate lawyer - one who will meet with you and spend time on your case. A lawyer who will fight for you. It's time to limit the number of cases court-appointed attorneys receive.

We sent a petition and a majority of Commissioners Court agreed they would vote to impose them, and their lawyer approved their legal authority to do so - all in open public court. Click here to hear the audio of their voiced support from that meeting on Oct. 27th. However, we still wait for any change or action to be taken on it - it’s been months. And while we wait, anywhere from 1,500 to 2,000 people/month are being harmed by being assigned an inadequate, overloaded attorney. Every moment is vital while we wait for action to be taken to restore the Sixth Amendment in Harris County.

THE PROBLEM: Harris County felony judges are operating a corrupt system that oppresses people merely because they are too poor to afford an attorney. The judges accept campaign contributions and in turn appoint individual attorneys an excessive indigent defense caseload, rendering them useless to provide our disadvantaged people any real voice or defense.

The most recent available data (2019) shows that 81% of people charged with crimes in Texas are indigent, meaning that they’re too poor to afford an attorney, so they receive either a public defender or a court-appointed attorney. In Harris County, the public defender's office provides zealous, holistic representation, but handles only 5% of these cases. You can check out this data reporting dashboard for information on which judges rarely appoint the public defender’s office to cases.

Most judges appoint private court-appointed attorneys instead of the public defender’s office, giving those private attorneys excessive caseloads. This results in over 70% of felony indigent defendants receiving court-appointed attorneys who exceed recommended caseload limits.

Ultimately, the quality of representation that indigent defendants receive is pathetic. Many of these overloaded court-appointed attorneys rarely visit their clients and do little work to investigate or litigate each case. They run up their payment vouchers simply by showing up to court and entering guilty pleas for their clients and helping the court quickly run through its docket. All while collecting hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars in income each year. Think about it: Would you want the attorney assigned to your criminal case to be handling 705 other cases that year? Or would you want them handling 128 other cases that year? The choice is obvious.

This corrupt system occurs at the expense of every taxpayer and wrongfully oppresses people for being poor, allowing their Constitutional rights to be sold out.

Every day, we get letters from people in jail in the greater Houston area begging for us to help them because their court-appointed attorneys are handling too many cases. We were founded to address this problem because it’s what matters most to people stuck in jail. Letters like this:

https://www.restoringjustice.org/caseloadlimits